top of page
  • Facebook

Bob Gary Responds to The Observer Editorial of September 30, 2026

On September 30, Matt Walsh, CEO and founder of Observer Media Group, published this editorial.

​

LBK Democratic Club board member, Bob Gary, has prepared this response and a letter to the editor based on this will be sent to The Observer shortly.

October 7, 2026

​

Matt Walsh is spot on in his recent column: “Americans should think before they vote and do their research.” I would ask Mr Walsh to do the same.  Mr Walsh's problem isn't that he believes in capitalism; it's that he turns legitimate questions about government into ideological absolutes that divide us at a time when our democracy is under threat and we most need to stand together to preserve what we love about this country. 

​

That is precisely why his argument demands a closer examination. I have given the assignment of responding to Mr. Walsh to ChatGPT. I have done that not because I am incapable of writing a coherent response. After all, I did just recently write a book. I am asking you to read a response not based on my personal opinion, but one written by a bloodless bot that seeks to unemotionally tone down the rhetoric and bring us together, rather than further divide us, at a time when decency, democracy, and the rule of law are under assault. A time when our taxpayer dollars are being diverted to pay for ads to support one man, a time when we are being promised cash to influence an election, and a time when corrupt government officials are making billions. You know where I am coming from.

​

What does a bloodless, computer-driven AI response say to Mr. Walsh, a response not burdened by emotions and ideology? This AI response is what follows. You should read it not because it is right but because it demonstrates how our opinions can be misinformed by a single voice, particularly one that owns the ink and the newsprint. 

 

What follows is ChatGPT's response to Mr. Walsh.  You can decide which fosters division and which seeks to unite us.

 

“His column makes legitimate points about government waste, healthcare fraud, inflation, federal spending and the importance of markets. Those are issues reasonable Republicans, Democrats and independents can debate.

​

But again and again, the column takes a legitimate fact and leaps to an ideological conclusion that the evidence does not establish.

​

That is not how we restore confidence in American democracy. At a time when our politics are already extraordinarily polarized, we need more intellectual honesty, not more political absolutism.

​

Consider Medicare for All.

​

There is a legitimate fiscal argument against a single-payer system. The Congressional Budget Office has estimated that various illustrative single-payer systems could increase federal healthcare subsidies by $1.5 trillion to $3 trillion in 2030. That is a serious issue that deserves serious debate.

​

But the CBO also found that the same systems could reduce out-of-pocket costs, provide nearly universal coverage, reduce administrative costs and, depending on how the system was designed, either increase or decrease total national healthcare spending.

​

That distinction matters.

​

Federal spending is not the same thing as total national spending. Under Medicare for All, Washington would take over expenditures that are currently paid by employers, families, insurers, and state governments.

​

One can reasonably oppose that change. But presenting the entire issue as "the government will spend another $3 trillion" without discussing what Americans currently spend privately is not a complete economic analysis.

​

 Mr. Walsh also points to the recent cancellation of more than 760,000 unauthorized Affordable Care Act enrollments as proof of the failure of government healthcare.

​

The number is real. CMS says those enrollments were unauthorized and estimates that approximately $2.2 billion in premium subsidies will be recovered.

​

But there is an obvious logical problem.

​

The existence of fraud in a government program demonstrates the need for effective oversight. It does not demonstrate that government healthcare is inherently incapable of working.

​

Indeed, the federal government's response to the problem—investigation, cancellation, enforcement and recovery of funds—is precisely what government oversight is supposed to do.

​

Mr. Walsh makes an even larger leap when he uses a South Florida PPP fraud case connected to the assassination of Haitian President Jovenel Moïse as evidence of the failure of government healthcare.

​

That case was horrific. The Justice Department has documented the use of fraudulently obtained pandemic-relief funds in financing the assassination plot.

​

But PPP was a business-relief program, not Medicare or Medicaid.

​

Using fraud in one federal program to prove that an entirely different federal program cannot work is not an economic argument. It is guilt by association.

​

The same problem appears in his discussion of inflation.

​

Mr. Walsh is correct that the federal response to COVID increased demand and contributed to inflation. But the assertion that Biden and the Democratic Congress are simply "the culprits" leaves out much of what economists have learned about the inflation episode.

​

The Federal Reserve documented pandemic supply bottlenecks, shortages, shifts in consumer demand and labor-market disruptions. Research by economists Ben Bernanke and Olivier Blanchard found that commodity-price shocks, supply constraints, changes in demand and labor-market conditions all contributed to the inflation surge.

​

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported 9.1% inflation in June 2022. But energy prices were up 41.6%, gasoline nearly 60%, and food 10.4%.

​

Those numbers don't prove that government spending was irrelevant. They demonstrate something more important: the causes were complicated.

​

Reducing a complicated economic event to "Biden printed money" may make for an effective political slogan. It does not make for good economic analysis.

​

Then comes the most sweeping claim of all: America is not a capitalist economy but a "statist" economy increasingly resembling Germany in the 1930s.

​

That comparison should concern anyone who values historical accuracy.

​

Germany in the 1930s was not simply a heavily regulated version of the American economy. It was a dictatorship that destroyed democratic institutions, eliminated political opposition, abolished independent trade unions, and brought civil society and economic organizations under Nazi control.

​

Americans can and should debate regulation, taxation, and the appropriate size of government without casually invoking Nazi Germany as an analogy.

​

There is another false choice running throughout the column: capitalism versus socialism.

​

America has never been purely one or the other.

​

Our economy combines private enterprise with Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, public education, public infrastructure, financial regulation, government research, military procurement, unemployment insurance and countless other public-private arrangements.

​

That doesn't mean every government program is good. It doesn't mean every regulation is sensible. It doesn't mean every tax is justified.

​

It means that the real debate is considerably more interesting than "capitalism or socialism."

​

And Americans themselves appear to understand that distinction.

​

A September 2026 Gallup survey found that capitalism was viewed positively by 55% of Americans and socialism by 43%. Among 18-to-34-year-olds, socialism received a positive rating of 57%, compared with 43% for capitalism. But Gallup specifically noted that the findings did not represent a wholesale movement away from markets toward socialism. Free enterprise remained broadly popular.

​

That is a much more nuanced picture than the one presented in Walsh's column.

​

Young Americans who say they favor "socialism" may be expressing concern about healthcare costs, college debt, housing prices, inequality or economic insecurity. They are not necessarily advocating government ownership of every factory, restaurant and small business in America.

​

We should listen to what they actually mean rather than caricaturing them.

​

There is also a great deal of truth in Walsh's praise of entrepreneurship. American capitalism has produced extraordinary innovation and prosperity.

​

But even here, the either-or argument doesn't hold.

​

Much American innovation has grown from a partnership between private entrepreneurs and public investment. Federal research funding, universities, government procurement and private capital have often worked together to produce technologies that later became commercial successes.

​

Markets matter. Government matters. Entrepreneurship matters. Public investment matters.

​

The challenge is figuring out where each works best.

​

That is a discussion worth having.

​

Calling one side "socialists," the other side "capitalists," and then declaring that one system is freedom and the other is slavery doesn't advance that discussion.

​\

It ends it.

​

And that may be the greatest problem with  Mr. Walsh’s column.

​

He begins by invoking James Madison's admonition that citizens should arm themselves with the power that knowledge gives. I agree completely.

​

But knowledge requires more than finding facts that support our existing ideology.

It requires acknowledging facts that complicate our argument.

​

It requires distinguishing fraud from inefficiency, federal spending from total national spending, correlation from causation, and democratic socialism from authoritarian dictatorship.

​

It requires recognizing that reasonable Americans can believe in free markets while also believing that Medicare provides something valuable. They can favor lower taxes while supporting Social Security. They can oppose excessive regulation while believing that government has a legitimate role in protecting consumers and competition.

​

That is not ideological confusion.

​

It is the American tradition of pragmatic democracy.

​

And there is a larger issue we should not lose sight of.

​

Our country is already deeply divided. Political polarization and institutional conflict are placing extraordinary stress on our democratic system. The 2026 Freedom House assessment continues to rate the United States as "Free," while warning that polarization and other pressures have hampered the ability of federal institutions to carry out basic responsibilities. V-Dem's 2026 report likewise documents a significant deterioration in several measures of American democratic institutions and political constraints.

​

Reasonable people can debate those assessments. But surely this is not the moment to pour gasoline on the fire with exaggerated claims that half of our fellow citizens are socialists, that government regulation makes America comparable to Nazi Germany, or that one political party should "scare the be-geebers" out of the public.

​

America does not need less disagreement.

​

It needs better disagreement.

​

We need Republicans who can criticize government without treating every government program as socialism.

​

We need Democrats who can defend social programs while acknowledging that government programs can waste money and need reform.

​

We need conservatives who understand that capitalism depends on the rule of law, functioning institutions, and public investment.

​

We need liberals who understand that markets, competition and private enterprise are indispensable sources of prosperity.

​

And we all need to recognize that our political opponents are fellow Americans—not enemies of America.

​

The stakes are too high for ideological caricature.

​

If Matt Walsh's challenge is that Americans should "do your research," then let us accept that challenge.

​

But let us do the research honestly.

​

Let's examine the evidence, acknowledge what we don't know, argue about policy rather than motives, and stop pretending that complicated problems have one-word answers.

​

That isn't liberalism.

​

It isn't conservatism.

​

It isn’t Democrats or Republicans.

​

It is simply what responsible citizenship requires.

 

Robert Gary

LBK Logo Horizontal.png
FLDems.png
Democrats.png
Sarasota Dems Logo.png
unnamed.png

Longboat Key Democratic Club

PO Box 8025   |   Longboat Key, FL 34228

Paid for and authorized by the Longboat Key Democratic Club

©2026 Longboat Key Democratic Club   |    Privacy Policy

bottom of page